|
Blog # 9 Text Analysis
I selected four types of texts that students read
routinely at my school.
|
||
|
Title and Type of
Text
|
Supportive Features
of Text
|
Challenging
Features
|
|
Non-Fiction
Build Our Nation-
Fifth Grade Social
Studies Textbook
|
·
Text explicitly
states and highlights the main idea for each section.
·
Text is divided
into two to three page sections.
·
Text makes use
of illustrations, captions, photographs, maps, and tables to add interest and
support the main ideas of the text.
|
·
Text assumes students have background
knowledge from previous social studies books in the same series.
·
Text is written at a seventh to eighth grade
reading level, according to an analysis using the Dale-Chall formula.
·
Text is laden
with content vocabulary
|
|
Non-Fiction
Foss Science Stories: Structures of Life
3RD Grade
|
·
Key vocabulary
is used frequently and in different stories that all support science
investigations taking place in the classroom.
·
Text has
engaging photographs and interesting information in the sidebars.
·
Text is short
enough to not overwhelm the third-grade reader.
·
Information is
logically organized.
·
Text frequently
links students' experiences (eating peanuts, for example) to science content
(peanuts are
seeds).
·
Text supports
experiments taking place in the classroom.
|
·
Text assumes students have some background
knowledge.
|
|
Fiction
First Grade
Decodable Texts –I Love Reading Booklets
|
·
Text matches phonics instruction.
·
Text contains only phonics features with which
students are familiar.
|
·
Texts are difficult to make meaning from
because of lack of content.
·
Texts are not engaging.
·
Texts are not written in a natural style.
|
|
Fiction
Houghton
Mifflin Vocabulary
Readers
Grade 3 - No More
Lost and Found
|
·
Book supports the key vocabulary studied in
the Houghton Mifflin Anthology and gives students additional exposure to key
vocabulary.
·
Purpose for reading is stated at the beginning
of the text.
·
Text introduces key vocabulary, with
definitions, before the story.
·
Vocabulary is highlighted in the story.
·
Pictures support understanding.
|
·
Text is not highly engaging.
·
No text features present.
|
Sunday, February 17, 2013
Blog # 9 Text Analysis
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment